Multiple Wagner Family Members Face Justice in Rhoden Murder Case

Ohio’s legal system has delivered new sentences in a chilling 2016 case involving the slaughter of the Rhoden family.

At a Glance

Jake Wagner was sentenced to life with a chance for parole after 32 years.
Angela Wagner has received a 30-year sentence, credited with time served.
Both individuals played roles in the murders of eight members of the Rhoden family.
The case highlighted Ohio’s largest legal investigation.

Overview of the Incident

In 2016, an Ohio family massacre shocked the nation when eight members of the Rhoden family were brutally killed. The crime reportedly stemmed from Edward “Jake” Wagner’s custody dispute with Hanna May Rhoden. The attack transpired across three mobile homes and a camper in rural Ohio, with two infants and a toddler being spared.

Authorities discovered this elaborate scheme months after the murders, prompting a thorough investigation. The case, known as one of Ohio’s most extensive prosecutions, captivated national attention.

In Pike County for sentencing Jake and Angela Wagner and Rita Newcomb in the Rhoden family massacre. pic.twitter.com/coxRgrR6np

— Lacey Crisp (@LaceyCrisp) January 3, 2025

Sentencing and Legal Proceedings

The case has led to significant sentences. Jake Wagner, after confessing and assisting in the investigation, has recently received a life sentence with possible parole after 32 years. His mother, Angela Wagner, has now received a 30-year sentence for helping with the murders, and Rita Newcomb, her mother, received probation and a fine for obstructing justice.

Despite admitting to killing five victims, Jake expressed remorse and claimed newfound faith. The judge contextualized Jake’s altered plea, aimed at resolving a longstanding legal agreement.

The case reveals deep reflections on motivations of human nature. Judge Hein commented on the depth of human behavior changes from seeking self-interest. Angela Wagner’s crucial role prompted discussions on accountability despite not physically partaking in the massacre.

“How do I resolve the good deal that your mom got?” Hein asked. “Thirty years is a really long time; that’s a really good deal for the level of the conduct. Especially since she could have stopped the whole thing dead in its tracks before it ever happened. And I don’t let her off the hook because she didn’t go to the scene. I put her equally responsible because the eyes of the law put her equally responsible.”

Not Over Yet

George Wagner IV, another member of the Wagner family accused in the plot, was previously convicted and sentenced to eight life sentences and 121 years in prison. In June, it was reported that he was seeking a new trial, claiming that prosecutors made errors that could have affected the jury’s decision.

Meanwhile, George “Billy” Wagner III is the only member of the family who has yet to get through his trial, which was set to begin on January 6. He is currently facing a total of eight charges of aggravated murder.

The crime’s tragic magnitude continues to emphasize justice and prevention strategies, underlined by Ohio’s pursuit of guardianship and fairness.