Alabama Police Department Hit By Massive Scandal

Nearly 60 felony cases are being dismissed in a small Alabama town after a grand jury uncovered widespread corruption and evidence tampering within the local police department, leading to multiple indictments including the police chief.

Quick Takes

A grand jury has deemed 58 felony cases “unprosecutable” in Hanceville, Alabama due to police corruption and evidence mishandling.
Four officers and the police chief were indicted on charges related to tampering with evidence.
An audit revealed 249 undocumented evidence items and 78 unsealed or torn evidence bags.
The investigation began after a police dispatcher died from an accidental drug overdose.
The Hanceville City Council has voted to disband and rebuild the entire police department.

Small Town Police Department Implodes Under Corruption Charges

The small town of Hanceville, Alabama, population 3,200, is reeling from revelations of extensive corruption within its police department. Following a thorough investigation by the Alabama State Bureau of Investigations, a grand jury determined that 58 felony cases were compromised by what they described as a “rampant culture of corruption” within the department. These cases, primarily drug-related offenses, are being dismissed as the evidence supporting them was either mishandled, tampered with, or completely removed from police custody.

Most of these cases involved drugs, and only a few were personal crimes with victims. One dismissal is too many, but the Grand Jury had no other recourse,” Cullman County District Attorney Champ Crocker stated.

Startling Evidence Room Audit Sparks Investigation

The scale of misconduct shocked investigators when the audit revealed that nearly 40% of evidence bags and almost a third of firearms in police custody were undocumented. The audit uncovered 249 pieces of evidence with no documentation whatsoever, along with 78 evidence bags that were either unsealed or torn open. This systematic breakdown in evidence management has rendered dozens of criminal cases legally untenable, allowing alleged criminals to walk free due to police negligence and misconduct.

The investigation began following the accidental drug overdose death of Christopher Willingham, a dispatcher with the Hanceville Police Department. The grand jury didn’t mince words about this tragedy, stating that the “death of former Hanceville dispatcher Chris Willingham is the direct result of Hanceville Police Department’s negligence, lack of procedure, general incompetence, and disregard for human life.”

Department Leadership Faces Serious Charges

The fallout from the investigation has been swift and severe. Five Hanceville police officers, including the police chief, were indicted on various charges related to evidence tampering and failure to report. Even the wife of one officer faces charges in connection with the corruption scandal. In February, Mayor Jimmy Sawyer placed the entire police department on leave pending the investigation’s outcome, and the city has since made more permanent plans for the department’s future.

Nearly 60 cases dismissed due to corruption in Alabama police departmenthttps://t.co/ErjSs8XOjl

— MSN Canada (@MSNca) May 9, 2025

A Fresh Start for Law Enforcement

The grand jury did not hold back in its assessment of the situation, recommending that the Hanceville Police Department be “immediately abolished” due to the extent of corruption uncovered. Following this recommendation, the Hanceville City Council voted to disband the department entirely. City officials have announced plans to rebuild the police force from the ground up, beginning with hiring a new police chief who can establish proper procedures and restore public trust in local law enforcement.

For the town of Hanceville, located 45 miles north of Birmingham, this scandal represents not just a failure of individual officers but a systemic breakdown of law enforcement integrity. The dismissal of 58 felony cases means that numerous alleged criminals will face no consequences for their actions, a fact that Cullman County District Attorney Champ Crocker acknowledged was deeply unfortunate but unavoidable given the circumstances of police misconduct.